By Cave News Times
Despite numerous policy decisions that have demonstrably hurt working-class Americans—especially in rural and red-leaning areas—Donald Trump continues to enjoy unwavering support from his MAGA base. To understand this phenomenon, we have to move past surface-level tribalism and explore the policies themselves: what they are, what they do, and why they either succeed or fail for the very people who support him most.
🔥 1. Tariffs: Economic Nationalism or Self-Destructive Isolationism?
Policy: Trump proposes up to 100% tariffs on all imported goods, affecting everything from electronics to cars to groceries.
Source: CNN – Trump’s new tariff threats
Why It’s Wrong:
- Higher Consumer Prices: Tariffs function like a tax on consumers. When imports are taxed, companies either raise prices or pass costs down the supply chain. Americans—especially low-income families—end up paying more for everyday goods.
- Supply Chain Damage: Manufacturers rely on imported parts. Tariffs drive up costs for U.S. businesses, potentially leading to layoffs or closures.
- Retaliation Risks: Other countries hit back with their own tariffs, harming U.S. exports like soybeans, pork, and wheat—products critical to Trump-supporting rural communities.
Who It Hurts: Small farmers, rural families, manufacturing workers—all core MAGA demographics.
🌾 2. USDA Cuts: Starving Small Farms While Feeding Big Ag
Policy: Cuts to USDA programs that supported independent farmers with debt relief, conservation, and climate resilience.
Source: Yahoo – USDA cuts
Why It’s Wrong:
- Independent Farms Lose Lifelines: The rollback of debt relief and subsidies increases the financial burden on small farms already struggling with droughts, inflation, and low crop prices.
- Corporate Advantage: The cuts don’t impact large agribusinesses that dominate lobbying and policy influence. The imbalance widens.
- Undermines Food Security: Small farms contribute to local food systems and resilience. Their collapse makes America more dependent on industrial farming and imports.
Who It Hurts: MAGA’s rural voters who often run family farms—and voted for Trump thinking he’d defend “the little guy.”
📉 3. Middle Class Collapse: A Legacy of Deregulation and Trickle-Down Failure
Policy: 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, deregulation of financial and labor markets.
Source: Indiana Law Journal – Decline of the American Middle
Why It’s Wrong:
- The Wealthy Got Richer: The tax reform overwhelmingly favored corporations and the top 1%, giving them windfalls without meaningful reinvestment in wages or jobs.
- Trickle-Down Myth: There was little evidence of sustained wage growth or job expansion in middle-income areas.
- Public Services Undermined: Tax cuts ballooned the deficit and were used to justify later cuts to healthcare, education, and infrastructure.
Who It Hurts: Working-class Americans who believed Trump would “drain the swamp” but ended up subsidizing billionaires.
🗳️ 4. Constitutional Violations: Executive Overreach
Policy: Executive order attempting to take federal control of election oversight.
Source: PBS – States sue over Trump’s election order
Why It’s Wrong:
- Violates Federalism: The Constitution grants states the right to manage their own elections. Trump’s order undermined that balance.
- Fuel for Conspiracy: Rather than improve election security, the order fed into disinformation about voter fraud, undermining public trust.
- Legal Overreach: 19 states sued, and multiple courts struck the order down as unconstitutional.
Who It Hurts: All Americans, but especially those in red states now subject to more scrutiny and instability in their electoral processes.
📋 5. A Broader Pattern of Harm: The Trump Admin Tracker
Policy Pattern: Across immigration, civil rights, environmental policy, and worker protections, Trump’s administration reversed regulations and implemented policies with far-reaching harm.
Source: Rep. Cohen’s Trump Admin Tracker
Examples of Harmful Policies:
- Environmental Rollbacks: Loosened pollution standards in communities already facing health risks—often in poor, rural areas.
- Labor Rights: Rolled back overtime pay protections and weakened the power of unions.
- Health Care Sabotage: Undermined the Affordable Care Act, risking coverage for millions with pre-existing conditions.
Who It Hurts: Workers, the disabled, low-income families, veterans—all part of Trump’s core base.
🧠 Why Do They Still Support Him?
- Cultural Identity Over Policy: For many, Trump represents a cultural rebellion, not a political leader. He “owns the libs” and that’s enough.
- Media Echo Chambers: Right-wing media reframes failures as victories and redirects blame to immigrants, Democrats, or “globalists.”
- Distrust of Government: Some voters accept short-term pain as a worthy cost of shaking up a system they see as corrupt.
✅ When Trump Got It Right (to be fair…)
While this article focuses on harmful outcomes, it’s important to acknowledge when policies helped:
- First Step Act: A bipartisan criminal justice reform law that reduced sentences for nonviolent offenders.
- Veterans Choice Program Expansion: Gave some veterans better access to private care (although this was an Obama-era program Trump expanded).
- Right-to-Try Act: Allowed terminally ill patients access to experimental treatments.
These policies had bipartisan support and reflect moments when governing took priority over culture wars.
🧭 Conclusion: Truth vs. Tribalism
Trump’s policies have repeatedly inflicted harm on the very Americans who chant his name at rallies. This isn’t just about political disagreement—it’s about real-world consequences: empty fields, rising prices, broken systems, and ignored communities.
But politics in 2025 isn’t just about facts—it’s about identity. As long as Trump is seen as a weapon against perceived enemies, many will continue to support him, no matter how deep the damage goes.
The job of independent media isn’t to preach, but to inform, show receipts, and let the truth speak louder than spin.
Discover more from Cave News Times
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Discussion about this post